Harness or Collar: Which is Best for Your Dog's Comfort and Safety?
Dog lovers, let’s settle the eternal debate: harness or collar? If you’ve ever wondered which is best for your dog’s comfort and safety, you’ve come to the right place. Whether you’re a new puppy parent or have a seasoned companion, finding the perfect gear is essential for happy walks and wagging tails.
The bottom line: What's the difference?
To begin with, what exactly is it?
A dog collar is that classic accessory that your pup probably wears all the time. It's great for ID tags, a quick leash attachment, and a touch of style. But if your dog is the type to dart after a passing bird, you may find that a collar doesn't always give you the control you need.
When it comes to dog harnesses, they are a kind of hug that distributes pressure across the chest and shoulders. They are perfect for puppies who like to pull or need to be guided.
Why choose a harness?
So why choose a harness over a collar? Is a harness better than a collar? Let’s take a closer look.
COMFORT & CONTROL: Imagine being held by the neck every time you get excited (ouch!). Harnesses are designed to distribute pressure, meaning there's less strain on your dog's neck and he's more comfortable during sniffing sessions.
SAFETY FIRST: For dogs who are prone to slipping out of their collars or those with sensitive throats, a harness can be a game changer. It’s safer, reduces the risk of injury, and gives you more control over your canine companion, especially if he thinks every walk is a sprint to the finish line.
Behavioral benefits: If your dog pulls like he's training for the next Iditarod, a harness is your new best friend. It discourages pulling by distributing the force throughout the body rather than concentrating it around the neck, which keeps the shoulders intact and reduces stress levels.
Great for Puppies: Your little dog hasn't learned how to walk nicely yet? You may be wondering if a harness is better than a collar for a puppy or if you should choose a collar or a harness for a puppy. A harness is great for training. Puppies often have fragile necks and a harness can prevent any potential damage while teaching them good habits from the start.
Dog Harness | Padouk™
Benefits of the necklace
Don't overlook collars just yet: they have some solid benefits, too.
Convenience is key: It's very easy to put on and take off a collar. They're great for ID tags and for puppies who are good on a leash. If your dog doesn't pull, tug, or take off like a rocket, a collar may be just what you need.
Ideal for training and identification: The collar is simple and effective if your dog is already a pro at walking on a leash. It is also practical for attaching essential identification tags, so that your four-legged friend can always find his way home if he decides to go on an unexpected solo adventure.
Perfect for short walks or calm dogs: If your dog is calm and doesn't need a lot of control, the collar can be a nice, easy-care option that's great for a quick stroll around the block or a casual stroll in the park.
Dog Collar | Shiny™
How to choose the right size? Factors to consider
So how do you choose between a harness and a collar? It's all about knowing what's best for your dog's specific needs. Here are some things to consider:
Your dog's size and breed: Smaller dogs, like Chihuahuas or Dachshunds, often benefit from a harness to avoid neck strain. Larger breeds that tend to pull, like Huskies or German Shepherds, also do well with one. Finally, calm, well-trained dogs of any size can get by with a collar.
Walking behavior: If your dog tends to pull, a harness can help control him and make walks more enjoyable for both of you. If your pup is a real trotster, a collar may be enough.
Age and training: A harness can gently guide and support puppies who are learning the ropes. For adult dogs who are already trained to walk gently, a collar may be more appropriate for everyday use.
Necklace Size Calculator
When to use both: harness and collar? Why not both?
How do you choose when you can have the best of both worlds? In the harness vs. collar debate, many dog owners find that using both works wonders. The collar stays on for identification and everyday wear, while the harness is used for long walks or training sessions where you need a little more control.
Think of it like your dog's wardrobe: a collar for casual days and a harness for adventures!
Expert advice and tips
Many experts agree that choosing between a harness and a collar should be based on your dog's unique behavior, size, and overall needs. For example, some veterinarians suggest using a harness for dogs with breathing problems or those prone to neck injuries, as harnesses distribute pressure more evenly across the body. According to the Australian Veterinary Association (AVA), harnesses are especially helpful for small breeds or dogs with fragile tracheas, such as pugs and French bulldogs, as they help reduce pressure on the neck and prevent injury.
For small dogs:
If you have a small dog or a breed with a sensitive neck, a lightweight harness designed for comfort and support may be ideal. The Formfit Mesh Harness is a great option for small dogs and puppies. Its breathable mesh fabric helps keep your dog cool and comfortable, while providing gentle, secure control during walks. This type of harness helps minimize potential neck strain and make walks more enjoyable for both of you.
Dogs that pull:
If your dog continues to pull despite reward-based training and a regular harness, collar and lead, RSPCA Australia also advises you to consider using a front-clip harness. A front-clip harness acts as a gentle training aid, discouraging pulling while allowing your dog to explore with enthusiasm. The X-Link harness is a great choice for dogs that tend to pull on the lead. Its front and back attachment points provide versatile control, helping to redirect your dog’s attention and reduce pulling behaviour. It’s perfect for maintaining a balanced walk, giving you greater control while keeping your dog comfortable.
Experts agree that the key to a safe and enjoyable walk is finding the right equipment for your dog’s specific needs and pairing it with consistent training. With the right combination, walking your dog can be the highlight of your day – relaxed, comfortable and fun!
Review: What is the verdict?
Ultimately, choosing a harness or collar depends on your dog's individual needs, personality, and your comfort during those all-important walks. Both options have their benefits, and the best choice is the one that keeps your dog safe, comfortable, and happy.
Use our: Necklace Size Calculator
Test it and give us your impression by joining our VIP list on sanedoggy.com.
Also benefit from a 10% discount on our sanedoggy.com store with the promo code COLLIER 10
